| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||
| 1 | BOS | Gustavo Chacin (BOS) | Jason Dubois (BOS) | Luke Hudson (BOS) | Justin Upton (U2-BOS) | Abraham Nunez (BOS) |
| 2 | SPO | Jorge Cantu (SPO) | Brad Halsey (MID) | Jose Lopez (SPO) | Nook Logan (SPO) | Pat Borders (SPO) |
| 3 | HIG | Chris Young (HIG) | Fernando Cabrera (HIG) | Thomas Diamond (U1-HIG) | Howie Kendrick (U2-HIG) | Hector Luna (ALL) |
| 4 | PNU | David Bush (PNU) | Bobby Madritsch (PNU) | Kelly Johnson (U1-PNU) | Chad Qualls (PNU) | Chien-Ming Wang (PNU) |
| 5 | SOU | Kevin Youkilis (SOU) | JD Closser (SOU) | Aaron Guiel (SOU) | Jason Frasor (SOU) | Dewyane Wise (SOU) |
| 6 | MID | Willy Taveras (MID) | Carlos Almanzar (DAK) | Humberto Cota (MID) | Alberto Castillo (BAL) | Kameron Loe (MID) |
| 7 | DAK | Jose Castillo (DAK) | Ian Snell (MID) | Jamie Burke (DAK) | Matt Guerrier (MID) | Juan Brito (DAK) |
| 8 | ALL | Nick Swisher (ALL) | Zach Duke (U1-ALL) | Carlos Quentin (U2-ALL) | Justin Germano (GAL) | Jairo Garcia (ALL) |
| 9 | DUR | Yhency Brazoban (DUR) | Ross Gload (DUR) | Robinson Cano (U2-DUR) | Joe Horgan (DUR) | Dave Krynzel (DUR) |
| 10 | BRE | Luis A Gonzalez (BRE) | Michael Morse (U1-BRE) | Jose Capellan (SEA) | Josh Willingham (ROG) | Huston Street (U2-BRE) |
| 11 | CHA | Russ Adams (CHA) | Chris Snyder (CHA) | Conor Jackson (U1-CHA) | Ian Stewart (U2-CHA) | Matt Wise (CHA) |
| 12 | SEA | Matt Holliday (SEA) | Ruben Gotay (MID) | Chris Burke (SEA) | Jon Adkins (MID) | Chris Aguila (SPO) |
| 13 | MEA | Akinori Otsuka (MEA) | Gabe Kapler (MEA) | Jamey Carroll (MEA) | Greg Aquino (MEA) | Tyler Walker (MEA) |
| 14 | NVG | Termel Sledge (NVG) | Jason Bartlett (MAD) | Jason Ellison (PHI) | JJ Hardy (U2-BAL) | Jon Leicester (MAD) |
| 15 | PHI | Joel Guzman (U2-PHI) | Alex Gordon (U1-NVG) | Ryan Langerhans (U2-MAD) | Mike Bacsik (PHI) | Gary Majewski (NVG) |
| 16 | MAD | Hayden Penn (MAD) | Merkin Valdez (PHI) | Ryan Zimmerman (U2-NVG) | Scott Dohmann (MAD) | Gabe Gross (PHI) |
| 17 | GEO | Tadahito Iguchi (GEO) | Victor Diaz (BOS) | Todd Williams (BAL) | Jeff Francoeur (U2-GEO) | Tanyon Sturtze (GEO) |
| 18 | ROG | Brad Hawpe (ROG) | Chris Shelton (MID) | Brendan Harris (ROG) | Jeff Bennett (DAK) | David Aardsma (ROG) |
| 19 | ANT | Dan Meyer (ANT) | Mike Adams (MET) | Kevin Correia (ANT) | John Danks (U1-MET) | Roman Colon (ANT) |
| 20 | MET | Yadier Molina (MET) | Jimmy Serrano (ANT) | Doug Brocail (MET) | Sun Woo Kim (ANT) | Brandon League (ALL) |
| 21 | GAL | David Newhan (NVG) | Justin Verlander (U1-GAL) | Nick Markakis (U2-GAL) | Cha Seung Baek (GAL) | Curtis Granderson (GAL) |
| 22 | TRI | Wilson Betemit (TRI) | Rene Rivera (TRI) | Maicer Izturis (TRI) | Kyle Davies (U1-TRI) | Damon Hollins (TRI) |
| 23 | ALI | Ryan Church (TRI) | Shawn Camp (ALI) | Olmedo Saenz (ALI) | Dan Johnson (U2-TRI) | Mike Gosling (ALI) |
| 24 | BAL | Orlando Hernandez (BAL) | Bob Wickman (BAL) | Lance Cormier (PHI) | Joe Roa (MEA) | Calvin Pickering (BAL) |
| 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | ||
| 1 | BOS | Jose Offerman (BOS) | Chin-Feng Chen (BOS) | Jay Powell (BOS) | Brian Daubach (BOS) | Casey Daigle (BOS) |
| 2 | SPO | Randy Choate (MAD) | Jorge De La Rosa (SPO) | Matt Treanor (SPO) | James Baldwin (SPO) | Lenny Harris (SPO) |
| 3 | HIG | Aaron Fultz (HIG) | Jason Romano (HIG) | Ryan Raburn (HIG) | Jon Knott (HIG) | Andy Machado (HIG) |
| 4 | PNU | Guillermo Quiroz (PNU) | Heath Bell (PNU) | PASS (PNU) | PASS (PNU) | PASS (PNU) |
| 5 | SOU | Gerald Williams (SOU) | Matt Thornton (SOU) | Chad Harville (SOU) | Jeff Niemann (U1-SOU) | Stephen Drew (U2-SOU) |
| 6 | MID | Ryan Doumit (MID) | Jack Cust (GAL) | Matt Kinney (DAK) | Danny Ardoin (MID) | Daric Barton (U2-DAK) |
| 7 | DAK | Tim Stauffer (MID) | Steve Sparks (DAK) | Roberto Novoa (MID) | Brandon McCarthy (U1-DAK) | Geoff Geary (MID) |
| 8 | ALL | John Grabow (ALL) | Josh Paul (GAL) | Brian Bruney (ALL) | Eric DuBose (GAL) | Kit Pellow (ALL) |
| 9 | DUR | George Sherrill (DUR) | Scott Atchison (DUR) | Eric Bruntlett (DUR) | Danny Garcia (DUR) | PASS (DUR) |
| 10 | BRE | Randy Flores (BRE) | Bucky Jacobsen (BRE) | Greg Dobbs (BRE) | Travis Blackley (BRE) | Jesse Garcia (BRE) |
| 11 | CHA | Denny Bautista (CHA) | Brad Hennessey (CHA) | Adam Bernero (CHA) | Freddy Guzman (CHA) | Bartolome Fortunato (CHA) |
| 12 | SEA | Jorge Piedra (SEA) | Eddy Rodriguez (SEA) | Chad Durbin (SEA) | Josh Kroeger (SEA) | Josh Hancock (SEA) |
| 13 | MEA | Dennys Reyes (MEA) | Stephen Randolph (MEA) | David Gassner (U2-MEA) | Pedro Astacio (MEA) | Herbert Perry (MEA) |
| 14 | NVG | Donnie Murphy (PHI) | Tim Harikkala (NVG) | Jason Grabowski (MAD) | Cliff Bartosh (PHI) | Denny Hocking (NVG) |
| 15 | PHI | Mike Jackson (MAD) | Abe Alvarez (PHI) | Matt Perisho (NVG) | Joe Borkowski (MAD) | Francis Beltran (PHI) |
| 16 | MAD | Kazuhito Tadano (NVG) | Justin Leone (MAD) | Carmen Cali (PHI) | Joe Valentine (NVG) | PASS (MAD) |
| 17 | GEO | JD Durbin (BAL) | Alfredo Amezaga (GEO) | AJ Hinch (GEO) | Ricky Gutierrez (GEO) | Andy Fox (GEO) |
| 18 | ROG | Scott Downs (ROG) | Chris George (ROG) | Brandon Larson (ROG) | Mike Mordecai (ROG) | Pat Hentgen (ROG) |
| 19 | ANT | John Wasdin (MET) | Michael Wuertz (ANT) | Chad Allen (MET) | Jeremi Gonzalez (ANT) | Rocky Biddle (MET) |
| 20 | MET | Jeff Keppinger (ANT) | Edison Volquez (U2-MET) | Tim Laker (ANT) | Joey Thurston (MET) | Alex Graman (ANT) |
| 21 | GAL | Jason Kubel (ALL) | Greg Norton (GAL) | Tim Salmon (GAL) | Sandy Martinez (GAL) | Howie Clark (GAL) |
| 22 | TRI | Terry Tiffee (TRI) | Jacob Cruz (TRI) | Trent Durrington (TRI) | Tony Torcato (TRI) | Adam Hyzdu (TRI) |
| 23 | ALI | Jose Bautista (ALL) | Edwin Encarnacion (U1-ALI) | Lance Niekro (U2-ALI) | Cody McKay (ALI) | AndyPhillips (ALI) |
| 24 | BAL | Val Majewski (BAL) | Andres Blanco (BAL) | Francisco Cruceta (BAL) | Logan Kensing (BAL) | Lenny DiNardo (BAL) |