| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||
| 1 | RAM | Matt Wieters (U2) | Nick Blackburn | Garrett Olson | Nyger Morgan | Jeff Benett |
| 2 | GEO | Joey Votto | Jed Lowrie (U2) | Brandon Jones | Blaine Boyer | Eric Patterson |
| 3 | WHI | Mark Reynolds | Pedro Alvarez (U1) | Radhames Liz | Ching-lung Hu (ALL) | Jim R. Johnson |
| 4 | RIE | Yunel Escobar | Asdrubal Cabrera | Troy Percival | Josh Anderson | Augie Ojeda |
| 5 | MIC | Joba Chamberlain | Sean Gallagher | Armando Galarraga | Omar Quintanilla | Kory Casto |
| 6 | CAL | Joakim Soria | Franklin Morales (GEO) | Wladimir Balentien (HIG) | Luis Ayala | Gary Glover |
| 7 | SEA | Matt Lindstrom | Jared Burton | Jensen Lewis | Brian Wolfe | Mike Bacsik |
| 8 | MET | Rick Ankiel | Matt Chico | Lance Broadway | Ryan Raburn | Brandon Moss |
| 9 | RCH | Jacoby Ellsbury | Joe Dillon | Joe Smith | Jason Botts | Ruben Gotay |
| 10 | MAD | John Lannan | Dana Eveland | Ben Francisco | Dennis Sarfate | Bryan Bullington |
| 11 | MID | Jair Jurrjens | Ian Kennedy | Andrew McCutchen (U2)(ALL) | Chris Volstad (U1) | Joel Hanrahan |
| 12 | ALI | Ryan Ludwick | Luke Hochevar | Ryan Rowland-Smith | Logan Kensing | Luis Mendoza |
| 13 | BAT | Lee Gardner | Jorge Campillo | Mike Fontenot | Luis A. Hernandez | Buddy Carylye |
| 14 | HAM | Clay Buchholz | Jesus Flores | Leo Nunez (CHA) | Greg Smith (U1) | Mike Moustakas (U2) |
| 15 | CHA | Clayton Kershaw (U1) | Max Scherzer (U2) | Justin Miller | Patrick Misch | Manny Acosta |
| 16 | WIN | Kyle Kendrick | Chase Headley | Brian Burres (MET) | Jason Heyward (U2) | Ryan Z. Braun |
| 17 | PNU | Jayson Werth | Cristian Guzman | Phil Dumatrait (MAN) | Hiroki Kuroda (U2) | Yorman Bazardo |
| 18 | MIL | Rick Porcello (U1) | Buster Posey (U2) | Ross Detwiler | Josh Wilson | Juan Gutierrez |
| 19 | BRE | Andy Sonnanstine | Brendan Ryan | Steve Pearce | Josh Banks | Kyle McClellan (U2) |
| 20 | GAL | Carlos Gomez (CHA) | Chris Tillman (U1) | Jake Arrieta (U2) | Curtis Thigpen | Tyler Clippard (MID) |
| 21 | ROG | Aaron Laffey (CAL) | Jo-Jo Reyes (GEO) | Dallas Braden (MID) | Danny Richar (MIC) | Fernando Martinez (U1) |
| 22 | BAL | Tim Redding | JR Towles (MET) | Jake McGee (U2) | Raul Casanova | Timo Perez |
| 23 | ALL | Jonny Cueto (U1)(GEO) | Manny Parra | Nate Schierholtz | Colby Rasmus (U2) | Joe Thatcher (GAL) |
| 24 | MAN | Kevin Cameron (SEA) | Matt LaPorta (U2) | Blake DeWitt (U1)(PNU) | Jamie Burke | Carlos Gonzalez (U1)(RIE) |
| 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | ||
| 1 | RAM | Jose Morales | Colt Morton | Billy Buckner | John Van Benschoten | Cody Ransom |
| 2 | GEO | Alex Cintron | Clint Sammons | Chase Wright | JD Durbin | Angel Berroa |
| 3 | WHI | Travis Metcalf | Guillermo Quiroz | Rick VandenHurk (ALL) | Justin Ruggiano | Carlos Martinez |
| 4 | RIE | Justin Masterson (U2) | Brayan Pena | Vinny Rottino | Franquelis Osoria | Gary Majewski |
| 5 | MIC | Tyler Walker | Shin-Soo Choo | Ryan Tucker (U1) | Ryan Budde (ROG) | Alcides Escobar (U2) |
| 6 | CAL | John Bale | Andy Gonzalez | Chris Bootcheck | Mark S. McLemore (ROG) | David Newhan |
| 7 | SEA | Chris Stewart | Scott Dohmann | Eulogio de la Cruz | Chris Spurling | Jason Wood |
| 8 | MET | Shelley Duncan | AJ Murray | Guillermo Rodriguez | Koyie Hill | Jason Ellison |
| 9 | RCH | Joe Borchard | Robert Fick | Matt Kata | Jon Coutlangus | Troy Cate |
| 10 | MAD | Brian Buscher | Daniel Barone | Tom Shearn | Craig Stansberry | Brad Salmon |
| 11 | MID | Eugenio Velez | Kevin Cash | Aquilino Lopez | Wade Davis (U2) | Julio Mateo (ROG) |
| 12 | ALI | Seth Smith | Ross Ohlendorf | Kevin Hart | Tommy Watkins | Nathan Haynes |
| 13 | BAT | Ehren Wasserman | Jonathan Albaladejo | Al Reyes | Sam Fuld | Lew Ford |
| 14 | HAM | Jonathan Meloan | Justin Maxwell (CHA) | JA Happ | Jorge Velandia | Mike Hessman |
| 15 | CHA | Emilo Bonifacio | Dee Brown | Brett Carroll | Scott Elarton | Alberto Castillo |
| 16 | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | Cory Wade (U2) | WIN |
| 17 | PNU | Carl Pavano (MAN) | Seth McClung | Mitch Stetter | DJ Houlton | Alberto Gonzalez |
| 18 | MIL | Felipe Paulino | JJ Furmaniak | JR House | Wil Nieves | Denny Bautista |
| 19 | BRE | Joe Koshansky | Donnie Murphy | Ryan Speier | Paul McAnulty | Kei Igawa |
| 20 | GAL | Troy Patton | Rocky Cherry | Jim Hoey | Jailen Peguero | Jae-Kuk Ryu |
| 21 | ROG | WIN | Alejandro De Aza (CAL) | Brian Rogers (ALI) | Wilson Valdez | Oscar Robles |
| 22 | BAL | Tike Redman | Jack Cassel | Bobby Livingston | Paul Hoover | Charlie Haeger |
| 23 | ALL | Jose Ascanio (MID) | Edwar Ramirez | Shawn Camp | David Aardsma | Edward Mujica |
| 24 | MAN | Sidney Ponson | VOID (Gabe Kapler) | Tony Batista | Jose Veras | PASS |