| # | Team | % | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| 1 | HAM | .352 | Mat Latos (HAM) | Jose Iglesias (U2)(HAM) | Kyle Blanks (ALL) | Matthew Downs (HAM) | Craig Tatum (CIN) |
| 2 | CAL | .358 | Aroldis Chapman (U1)(MAN) | Drew Storen (U2)(CAL) | David Huff (CAL) | Michael Brantley (CAL) | Steven Jackson (CAL) |
| 3 | ELP | .364 | Mike Stanton (U1)(ELP) | Tanner Scheppers (U2)(ELP) | Sean West (ELP) | David Hernandez (ELP) | Jess Todd (ELP) |
| 4 | WHI | .389 | Brett Cecil (WHI) | Chris Narveson (WHI) | Fu-Te Ni (WHI) | Miguel Batista (WHI) | Tommy Mazella (WHI) |
| 5 | GAL | .395 | Kris Medlen (GAL) | Gaby Sanchez (FLA) | Tyler Matzek (U2)(GAL) | Carlos Carrasco (GAL) | Jeff Manship (MID) |
| 6 | MIL | .432 | Starlin Castro (U1)(MIL) | Domonic Brown (U2)(MIL) | Blake Hawksworth (MIL) | Dan Runzler (MIL) | Josh Reddick (MIL) |
| 7 | NYK | .438 | Kyle Drabek (U1)(NYK) | Tim Stauffer (NYK) | Brad Kilby (NYK) | Jose Morales (NYK) | Josh Thole (NYK) |
| 8 | TRE | .444 | Ike Davis (U1)(TRE) | Jake Fox (TRE) | Logan Morrison (U2)(TRE) | Andres Blanco (TRE) | Eli Whiteside (TRE) |
| 9 | MIC | .457 | Chris Coghlan (MIC) | Brian Duensing (MIC) | Danys Baez (MIC) | Shawn Kelley (MIC) | PJ Walters (MIC) |
| 10 | RCH | .469 | Jennry Mejia (U1)(RCH) | Craig Stammen (MAD) | Tony Sanchez (U1)(ALL) | Zach Britton (U1)(MAD) | JD Martin (RCH) |
| 11 | MAD | .469 | Ian Desmond (MAD) | Marc Rzepczynski (RCH) | Jeff Weaver (MAD) | Mike Carp (ALL) | Rick VandenHurk (MAD) |
| 12 | SDR | .494 | Luke Gregerson (SDR) | Sean White (SDR) | Ramiro Pena (SDR) | Luis Durango (SDR) | Hank Conger (U2)(SDR) |
| 13 | SAS | .500 | Andrew Bailey (SAS) | Desmond Jennings (U1)(SAS) | Kyle Gibson (U2)(SAS) | Lucas French (SAS) | John Axford (SAS) |
| 14 | BAL | .506 | Jesus Montero (BAL) | Jeremy Hellickson (U2)(BAL) | Adam Rosales (BAL) | Nick Green (BAL) | Sam Fuld (BAL) |
| 15 | MET | .531 | Alex Gonzalez (MET) | Jason Jaramillo (MET) | Jason Berken (MET) | Clay Zavada (MET) | Chris Ray (MET) |
| 16 | RAM | .543 | David Freese (RAM) | Tyler Flowers (RAM) | Juan Francisco (RAM) | Deck McGuire (U2)(RAM) | Donald Veal (RAM) |
| 17 | FLA | .556 | Bryce Harper (U2)(FLA) | Jason Vargas (BRE) | Trevor Crowe (HAM) | John Ely (U1)(BRE) | Matt Belisle (FLA) |
| 18 | BRE | .556 | Doug Fister (BRE) | Drew Stubbs (FLA) | Tyler Colvin (BRE) | Kevin Jepsen (FLA) | Josh Wilson (BRE) |
| 19 | ROG | .580 | Mike Leake (U1)(MAN) | Andres Torres (CAL) | Andrew Lambo (U1)(ROG) | George Kottaras (HAM) | Brett Carroll (MID) |
| 20 | ALL | .617 | Garrett Jones (ALL) | Alex Avila (FLA) | Daniel Schlereth (ALL) | Felipe Paulion (ALL) | Antonio Bastardo (MID) |
| 21 | RIE | .623 | Michael Saunders (RIE) | Bud Norris (MIC) | Jordan Schafer (GAL) | Esmil Rogers (RIE) | Rusty Ryal (RIE) |
| 22 | PNU | .636 | Austin Jackson (U1)(HAM) | Tony Sipp (MAN) | Martin Perez (U2)(PNU) | Sergio Mitre (MAN) | Justin Maxwell (PNU) |
| 23 | MAN | .636 | Jhoulys Chacin (MAN) | Zach Stewart (U2)(NYK) | Landon Powell (MAN) | Samuel Gervacio (PNU) | Adam Russell (MAN) |
| 24 | MID | .654 | Jose Tabata (U2)(MID) | Daniel Hudson (MID) | Adam Moore (MID) | Neil Walker (ALL) | Eric Young Jr (MID) |
| # | Team | % | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| 1 | HAM | .352 | Corey Patterson (MAN) | Carlos Rosa (HAM) | Dan Richar (HAM) | Luis Cruz (HAM) | Chris Gimenez (ROG) |
| 2 | CAL | .358 | Dirk Hayhurst (CAL) | Guillermo Moscoso (CAL) | Kevin Frandsen (CAL) | Sean Green (CAL) | Chris Smith (CAL) |
| 3 | ELP | .364 | Xavier Paul (ELP) | Trevor Bell (ELP) | Cesar Ramos (ELP) | Michael Dunn (ELP) | Sean O'Sullivan (ELP) |
| 4 | WHI | .389 | Shawn Hill (WHI) | Kevin Cash (WHI) | Omar Quintanilla (WHI) | Leo Rosales (WHI) | Roman Colon (WHI) |
| 5 | GAL | .395 | Sergio Escalona (GAL) | John Mayberry (GAL) | Henry Rodriguez (GAL) | Ryan Rohlinger (GAL) | Tug Hulett (ROG) |
| 6 | MIL | .432 | Brandon Allen (MIL) | PASS (MIL) | PASS (MIL) | PASS (MIL) | PASS (MIL) |
| 7 | NYK | .438 | Ken Takahashi (NYK) | Matt Daley (NYK) | Billy Buckner (NYK) | Kelvim Escobar (NYK) | Wilkin Ramirez (NYK) |
| 8 | TRE | .444 | Esmerling Vasquez (TRE) | Brett Hayes (TRE) | Tim Wood (TRE) | Luis Hernandez (TRE) | Andy Gonzalez (TRE) |
| 9 | MIC | .457 | Nick Stavinoha (MIC) | Jeff Gray (MIC) | Luis Atilano (U2)(MIC) | Josh Roenicke (MIC) | Kevin Cameron (MIC) |
| 10 | RCH | .469 | Freddy Garcia (MAD) | Michel Hernandez (RCH) | Jacob Turner (U2)(MAD) | Wyatt Toregas (RCH) | Alfredo Simon (MAD) |
| 11 | MAD | .469 | DeWayne Wise (RCH) | Justin Turner (MAD) | Paul Phillips (RCH) | Luis Ayala (MAD) | Robb Quinlan (RCH) |
| 12 | SDR | .494 | Chris Jakubauskas (SDR) | Edwin Maysonet (SDR) | Trent Oeltjen (SDR) | Ernesto Frieri (SDR) | Jesus Guzman (SDR) |
| 13 | SAS | .500 | Matt Maloney (SAS) | Brooks Conrad (SAS) | Rodrigo Lopez (SAS) | Juan Miranda (SAS) | Denny Bautista (SAS) |
| 14 | BAL | .506 | Bobby Scales (BAL) | Esmailin Caridad (BAL) | Darnell McDonald (BAL) | Edwin Bellorin (BAL) | Ryan Webb (BAL) |
| 15 | MET | .531 | Elmer Dessens (MET) | Koji Uehara (MET) | Doug Mathis (MET) | Rich Hill (MET) | Josh Barfield (MET) |
| 16 | RAM | .543 | Anthony Swarzak (RAM) | Dontrelle Willis (RAM) | JoJo Reyes (RAM) | Brian Wolfe (RAM) | Junichi Tazawa (RAM) |
| 17 | FLA | .556 | Carlos Fisher (BRE) | Tony Abreu (FLA) | Eddie Bonine (BRE) | Daniel McCutchen (FLA) | Don Kelly (BRE) |
| 18 | BRE | .556 | Rogearvin Bernadina (FLA) | Brennan Boesch (U2)(BRE) | Drew Sutton (FLA) | John Hester (BRE) | Jorge Sosa (FLA) |
| 19 | ROG | .580 | Tyler Greene (HAM) | Andrew Carpenter (GAL) | Reggie Willits (ROG) | Greg Burke (MID) | Mike Burns (ROG) |
| 20 | ALL | .617 | Michael Aubrey (ALL) | Josh Bell (U2)(ROG) | Brad Lincoln (U2)(ALL) | Kevin Mulvey (ALL) | Nick Adenhart (GAL) |
| 21 | RIE | .623 | Wilson Valdez (RIE) | Michael Taylor (U1)(RIE) | Dusty Hughes (RIE) | Bradley Meyers (U2)(RIE) | Tommy Everidge (RIE) |
| 22 | PNU | .636 | Radhames Liz (MAN) | Charlie Haeger (PNU) | Brett Tomko (MAN) | Alberto Castillo (PNU) | PASS (MAN) |
| 23 | MAN | .636 | Randy Choate (PNU) | Sergio Santos (U2)(MAN) | Cody Ransom (PNU) | PASS (MAN) | Chin-Lung Hu (PNU) |
| 24 | MID | .654 | Luis Perdomo (MID) | Carlos Torres (MID) | Craig Gentry (MID) | Alfredo Figaro (MID) | Justin Berg (ROG) |